Online learning challenges in Thailand and strategies to overcome the challenges from the students’ perspectives

Recently, at the end of 2019, the whole world was affected by the outbreak of COVID − 19 disease, which has caused massive disruption of the normal teaching and learning process worldwide, including Thailand’s educational system. This sudden shift of the educational processes to online learning and teaching has caused many challenges as teachers, learners, and educational institutes are not well-prepared, especially in developing countries like Thailand. This research used a mixed-methods approach, quantitative and qualitative data, in which a google form survey questionnaire was designed in both English and Thai language to 1). investigate Thai students’ perceptions of the online learning experience; 2). assess factors that cause challenges in online learning in Thailand; 3). find out strategies for improvement and overcome the challenges. For the sample of the study, 465 students were selected purposively from two public Universities in Thailand due to convenience for collecting data as two co-researchers were teaching in these universities. Results identified major challenges such as the temptation to see other sites, difficulty in understanding the lesson context, poor internet connectivity, difficulty in time management, difficulty in attending the online examination, poor quality of learning experience, low interest/motivation, difficulty in selecting the area at home, difficulty in doing work assignment/task, and distraction at home learning environment. Among the identified factors for these challenges were distraction due to noise and poor learning environment at home, teacher’s incompetency due to technical, poor teaching skills, unstructured content or no follow-up, and technological constraint affecting the quality of audio/video uploaded connectivity, technical issue or data limit. Students also suggested strategies to overcome online learning challenges such as improvement in evaluation, connectivity, interactivity, content and accessing materials. The study concluded that all these factors and strategies should be considered for the effective implementation of the online education system in Thailand.


Literature review
Before proceeding to the methodology of the study, it is essential to define the concept of online education. It is a mode of teaching and learning in an online environment having internet connectivity (Singh & Thurman, 2019). There have been many studies recently on this issue of online education challenges (Maatuk et al., 2022;Rasheed et al., 2020). Due to the pandemic, all education was switched rapidly to the online system and this caused many challenges as an unfavorable study environment, unstable internet connectivity, eye strain, depression, anxiety, and social isolation, which affected academic performance, mental and physical welfare of students (Li & Che, 2022;Kapasia et al., 2020). Many students were stressed about their academic achievement, assignment load, technical difficulties, and doubt about the efficiency of instruction techniques, and evaluation methods (Fawaz et al., 2021). Adarkwah (2021) identified critical factors that affect the online learning experience among students in Ghana during the pandemic. The result indicated several challenges that students faced in online learning, such as social isolation, lack of interaction and communication, inadequate ICT resources, housing problems, usually living in a small house with limited internet connectivity, lack of up-to-date devices, and no facility for laboratory work (Day et al., 2021). This has been supported by Barrot et al. (2021) who reported on students' experience with online learning and its psychological impact. Their study found the selection of an ideal room or place at home with no disturbance from family or a nearby outside environment as the biggest challenge. And the most frequently adopted strategies adopted by students were resource and time management, control of the learning environment, enhancement of technical knowledge, etc. Muthuprasad et al. (2021) investigated students' views and inclinations toward online learning. The result revealed that many students used smartphones, and preferred recorded classes containing tests after class, flexibility, and convenience to foster success in learning online. Among many challenges, the top challenge of online learning was the lack of connectivity, and factors contributing to the success of online learning were course content, available online infrastructure, instructor competency, student preparation, and follow-up. There were other challenges such as finding an ideal room or place for learning at home, inadequate knowledge of internet technology, the burden of internet bill payment, and restricted time for friendship with peer groups (Suryaman et al., 2020). Aboagye et al. (2020) explored challenges from the student's perspective on online learning during the pandemic as decreased motivation, accessibility, connectivity, lack of appropriate devices, and feeling of isolation due to lack of communication and interaction with teachers and peers. Also, Coman et al. (2020) reported poor teaching outcomes with challenges such as technical issues, teachers' lack of technical skills, improper teaching style, and poor interaction and communication between teachers and students in online education. Concerning improvement strategies in online learning, Bao (2020) identified six teaching strategies that are considered relevant for effective online education. These strategies include (1) improvement of instructional design to enhance students' learning; (2) effective delivery of online instruction; (3) support provided to students by teaching staff; (4) quality of participation to improve overall learning of students; (5) plan to solve online education problems. Mahmood (2021) also suggested strategies for online teaching improvement such as the collaboration of educational commission with telecommunication industries for stable internet supply, getting feedback from students, and availability of flexible teaching according to students' convenience and policies for assessment. To date, there have been only a few studies on online education challenges in Thailand. Recently, a study was conducted on Thai students' perception of online learning and it has been reported that the majority of students in Thailand preferred onsite to online classes and are not ready to learn online even in the future too (Imsa-ard, 2020). To solve the challenges of sudden switching from onsite to online classes, under the impact of the COVID-19 restriction protocol, Mahidol University Thailand, employed a blended mode of education, that is, onsite as well as online classes, based on the nature of study programs strictly following the procedure to control the spread of the disease (Mahaisavariya, 2020).

Methodology
This research used a mixed-methods approach, consisting of both quantitative and qualitative data, obtained by using a survey questionnaire, to investigate challenges that students encountered in online learning and strategies to overcome those challenges from the participant students' perspective.
The conceptual framework of this study is adapted from the work of previous research on students' experience of challenges in online learning as given below in Fig. 1 (Rasheed et al., 2020;Barrot et al., 2021) and Fig. 2 (Carillo & Flore, 2020).

Participants
The sample of the study consisted of 465 students (246 men and 219 women) from two public Universities in Thailand, viz. Rajabhat University (RU), Sakhon Nakhon and Mahachulalongkornrajavidyalaya University (MCU), Khonkaen. These participants were Buddhism, Philosophy, Thai language, Political Science, Social Studies, and Public Administrator majors whose ages ranged from 18 to 58 (x ̅ = 19.97; SD = 6.92). There were 252 students from Rajabhat and 213 from MCU. The sample of the study, 465 students, was selected purposively from these two Universities due to convenience for collecting data. Three co-researchers were teaching at these Universities and the selected sample was their students. So, it was easier to collect data from their students, than collecting data from a distant University with which researchers have no connection. Table 1 shows the demographic characteristics of student participants. Most participants were undergraduate Bachelor's degree students in 1st year (57.4%).

Data collection procedures
The data was collected through a questionnaire that the researcher designed based on the literature studied (Saha et al., 2022;Rajab et al., 2020;Muthuprasad et al., 2021), consisting of both closed and open-ended questions. The questionnaire consists of five sections. The first section of the questionnaire included the demographic characteristics of student participants. The second section of the questionnaire was * BA = Bachelor of Arts on the online learning experiences of students, which contained eight items. The third section of the questionnaire was on challenges that students faced in online learning and it contained twenty items, designed on four levels of challenges (No, Low, Medium, and High). The fourth section of the questionnaire was on factors affecting the success of online classes, which contained five items and each item has two to six sub-items. The last section of the questionnaire was on factors that caused challenges in online classes and strategies to overcome those challenges. The questionnaire was first set in English language and then translated into the Thai language to aid the understanding of Thai students since English is a foreign language in Thailand and most students could not read or write English language. The translated questionnaire was then uploaded to 'Google Forms', which is an online survey tool from 'Google'. The link to the questionnaire was created and then shared with the respective coresearchers representing the two Universities via Email and social media platforms like Line and Messenger applications with a permission letter informing the purpose of this research and ensuring the privacy and confidentiality matter, that the provided information would not be shared with anyone and to be used only for research purposes. The participants responded to the survey questionnaire anonymously. The survey questionnaire was administered to students during the first and third week of the first semester for the academic year 2022-2023 by sending the link to Google forms through online media, such as Email, Line, and Facebook applications. It was sent to the two universities' co-researchers with an official letter appealing to them to distribute the questionnaire to their students. They were requested to finish filling up the questionnaire in 15 days. The questionnaire was completed between July 18 and August 4, 2022.

Data availability
Data of this study is available in Google Forms. However, it is not shared publicly as it is kept confidential and anonymous.

Data analysis
After receiving all responses in the Google form shared with all student participants, the researcher closed to receive responses in the form. Then, the collected empirical data in Google form were analyzed by grouping them into tables with the calculation of appropriate descriptive statistical computation as frequency distribution, mean, and standard deviation wherever necessary and relevant.

Problem confrontation index (PCI)
Challenges faced by students in this study were analyzed using Problem Confrontation Index (PCI) adapted from a previous study (Saha et al., 2022), which was classified into a four-point rating scale for measuring scores. The students' participants were asked to identify the rating of 20 major challenges they faced in online learning. Each response was given a weight: 3 for the high-level challenge, 2 for the mediumlevel challenge, 1 for the low-level challenge, and 0 for no challenge. Then, for each challenge, the Problem Confrontation Index (PCI) was calculated using the following formula: In Eq. (1), P H = Number of participants that expressed challenges as 'High'; P M = Number of participants that expressed challenges as 'Medium'; P L = Number of participants that expressed challenges as 'Low'; and P N = Number of participants that expressed challenges as 'No'. Thus, the PCI of students' challenges was ranked.

Online learning experiences of students
As can be seen from Table 2, most participants spent more than 5 h per week (54.83%), followed by 27.10% of students who spent 3-4 h per week, while another 18.07% spent 1-2 h per week in online classes. Regarding the device used for online  learning, most students' participants (74.20%), used smartphones, followed by laptops or desktop computers (15.0%). Most students answered that they used Mobile data packs (56.10%) for internet connection in online learning, followed by Wi-Fi (41.50%). Regarding the platform for online learning, most participants learned in the Zoom cloud meeting (47.74%), followed by Google meet (31.40%), and Google classroom (20.86%). In the case of the type of classes attended by the students, most participants answered both theoretical and practical (49.70%), followed by theoretical (46.20%). The study found that 72.90% of students had a medium attendance level, and another 26% of students had attended had a high attendance level in online classes. The online platform was not only used for conducting classes but also for giving examinations. Results reported that 89.20% of participants had an examination during this pandemic using an online platform. Regarding the type of examination conducted, most students were evaluated with Quiz (70.10%), followed by Written Test (11.60%), an Assignment (8.0%), and so on.

Challenges in online learning
In the case of Thailand, onsite education was swiftly switched to online mode to save the academic year of education during the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown without much preparation or training for both teachers and students. So, students faced many challenges because they were used to normal onsite face-to-face classes where teachers and students were physically present and interacted in the classroom for any query. To find out these challenges, students were asked to identify and rank several challenges. The ranking of these challenges as identified by the students' participants is shown in Table 3. On analysis of Table 3, most students were distracted and had the temptation to see other sites while having online classes (ranked 1), followed by difficulty in understanding the lesson context (ranked 2), poor internet connectivity (ranked 3), difficulty in time management (ranked 4), difficulty in attending online examination (ranked 5), poor quality of learning experience (ranked 6), low interest or motivation (ranked 7), difficulty in selecting the study area at home and in doing homework assignment (ranked 8), got distracted or disturbed at home ( ranked 9), and limited technological experience (ranked 10) were the top 10 challenges. Other apparent challenges that students faced were tests and evaluation, limited opportunity for student and teacher interaction, lack of proper guidance for using the course, inadequate ICT infrastructure, low concentration, lack of training, insufficient feedback from the teacher, poor self-discipline, and feeling of social isolation. One major obstacle faced by students to online learning is an unstable internet connection similar to the previous research findings (Maatuk et al., 2022). Students' distraction and inattentiveness to the temptation to see other sites have been reported in previous studies too (Khan et al., 2021.) which hinder students' learning in online classes (Flanigan & Babchuk, 2022). The challenge of difficulty in understanding the lesson context and low motivation of students can be improved through the development of social presence, that is, building interaction, collaboration, and relationships between teachers and students through various social networks, such as blogs, chat, forum, or video conferences, etc. So, it is important to consider key issues, including an accurate pedagogical approach, homework offline assignments, and appropriate tools and technology while creating an effective online learning environment (Carillo & Flores, 2020). Selecting an appropriate learning environment at home is another big challenge based on socioeconomic factors as reported in another recent study (Barrot et al., 2021). Poor learning environments, inadequate space, and lack of field or laboratory work negatively impact learning, engagement, and concentration causing stress and anxiety to students (Walters et al., 2022;Day et al., 2021;Suryaman et al., 2020). Some of the common distractions during online learning include noise from the environment. So, family and parents should cooperate to find suitable solutions to minimize noise or distract students while having online classes at home.

Factors affecting the success of online classes
The participants were also asked some qualitative open-ended questions about some major factors which could affect the success of online classes. These major factors were the nature of the content, infrastructure, competency, readiness, and follow-up as given in Table 4. The highest theme or sub-factor of the nature of content factor was accessibility (38.50%), followed by interactivity and relevancy (20.60%), the structure of the lesson content (15.30%), comprehensiveness (13.10%), and flexibility (12.50%). This supports the findings of Muthuprasad et al. (2021). The second factor, infrastructure has the following themes or sub-factors ranked from top to bottom such as (1) connectivity (30.50%), (2) video/audio quality (23.90%), (3) Data pack (20.40%), (4) Data speed (12.50%), and (5) Devices (12.70%). This sug-gests the role of contextual factors (limited access to internet technology) impacting the quality of teaching and learning experience which should not be ignored (Beaunoyer et al., 2020). Regarding the factor of competency, the highest score theme / sub-factor was communication (63.70%), followed by technical (26.90%), and other strategies to motivate students (9.50%). The next important factor is the readiness to learn online, having themes or sub-factors ranked from top to bottom as motivation (43.88%), discipline (33.98%), focus (21.50), etc. Last is the factor of follow-up, having an important theme/sub-factor as improvement in evaluation or test (99.35%) for successful online learning.

Factors that caused challenges in online classes and strategies to overcome
On analysis of the qualitative open-ended questions on factors that caused challenges in online classes and strategies to overcome, we found major factors such as technological constraint, distractions, teacher's competency, learner's inefficacy, and suggestion for improvement as given in Table 5 and Table 6. From Table 5 and Table 6, it was found that a high proportion of the participants considered connection (41.90%) and audio/video (35.50%) as the major themes for technological constraint challenges. At times, the students were frustrated while learning from slow mobile internet interaction, as slow connection caused poor intermittent audio and video quality similar to the findings of Maatuk et al. (2022). To overcome the internet access challenges based on contextual factors (Beaunoyer et al., 2020), the students need a fast and stable internet connection during the online class platform for accessing study materials, with clear video and audio quality. Improving this challenge will help to make the online class platform to be smooth and more interesting. Another top challenge in online learning according to these students was distraction caused by noise  (68.0%) and poor learning environment (29.0%). Noise caused students' distracted from hearing or concentrating on the lesson. Some students said they were distracted by somebody knocking at the door, started calling, loud voices of neighbors talking, dog barking, or house construction. So, learners need an ideal peaceful learning environment without disturbance while having online classes at home which supports the findings of Li and Che (2022) that indicated learning environment is one-factor affecting students' academic performance in online education. The selection of an appropriate learning environment at home is based on socioeconomic factors (Barrot et al., 2021;Adarkwah (2021). Under the 3rd factor, which is the teacher's incompetency in online teaching, the major themes listed were technical constraint (57.80%), poor teaching skills (18.10%), unstructured content (15.50%), and no follow-up (8.60%). To solve this challenge, it is important to improve teachers as reported in previous research too (Bao, 2020;Zhang et al., 2020) by providing ICT skills training to online teachers so that they become excellent in adopting online teaching methodology. Some unskilled teachers gossip about irrelevant things instead of teaching the subject matter, thus failing to impart accurate knowledge to learners. Therefore, teachers need to adopt effective teaching practices relating to the use of pedagogical tools and technologies such as blogs, chat, forums, gamification, videos, quiz, animated clips, and other tools and activities to bring students' interest to make them learn faster (Carrillo & Flores, 2020). Also, the course content should be divided into several small relevant and updated modules (Bao, 2020), and not lengthy which cannot be completed. Incomplete teaching due to time constraints should be summarized and briefly explained to students. To solve the problem of incomplete lessons, teachers can assign tasks that employ a combination of online learning and offline self-learning by providing feedback on the work of students' assignments. The teacher should not include questions that have not been taught to  The teacher should be skilled in this field, and teach the subject matter instead of gossiping to impart the knowledge to learners.
"Teachers should not put pressure on students unnecessarily, should provide students to interact and speak instead of the teacher speaking alone" Unstructured content The course content should be brief, relevant, and completed "Incomplete teaching due to time constraint causes the course to end without completion" No follow-up The teacher has no time to test students' feedback or questions to answer students' problems or doubts "The course content which is not completed by the teacher should be explained briefly to students and untaught lessons should not be set in the test" Learner's inefficacy Focus Need to monitor students to focus on the lesson as many students lose interest in learning.
"Most of the time inattentive and diverted with the temptation to do multiple tasks during online learning" Unmotivated Lack of motivation with no friends and a teacher "Similar to onsite learning, the teacher has a great role to motivate students. Online classes are boring with no friends to interact" Indiscipline Boredom, inattentiveness, laziness, and not punctual "Indiscipline as students are left to control themselves, often they do other things while having class" Style of teaching/presentation/ Network Improve the content and the presentation style and good internet network "Some teacher teachers same like speaking alone". "Inability to attend class in the absence of internet mobile data or Wi-Fi" 5. Improvement Suggestion

Evaluation
After completing a lesson, the teacher should check the understanding of students of what is being taught through tests and evaluations.
"Homework or an assignment after the lecture will help the teacher to check the level of understanding of students"

Connectivity
Internet connectivity should have a good signal and be fast. Students need to be prepared with a mobile phone, tablet, computer, or notebook with an internet connection "If the internet is slow, or congested, the sound quality and the video is interrupted, it affects learning. Got stuck sometimes without getting access" Interactivity Organize online group activities to answer questions, to promote students' attention through the use of the problemsolving application "Provide activities to students to motivate students, reduce boredom, and make the lesson more interesting. Teachers and learners can do online chat activities to ask and answer questions" Content The content of the course should be brief, concise, easy, up-to-date, and applicable to daily life "If the content is complex and tough, it will put pressure on students" Accessing materials Accessing material should not be difficult.
Upload teaching videos such as documentaries and provide access to students to save the lesson "The quality of the instructional videos is sometimes blurry and cannot be accessed. Need to save the lesson so that we can watch and listen to it many times" students in the evaluation test. In this way, teachers will lessen unnecessary pressure on students. Many teachers have no time to test students' feedback in a hurry to finish the class or course. These findings indicate the key role of teachers in the success of online learning as reported in previous research (Flores et al., 2022). The participants identified themes as focus (37.60%), unmotivated (36.60%), and indiscipline (21.90%) under the 4th factor (learner's inefficacy). While learning online, students have the freedom to do it on their own as it is quite different from onsite classes. So, most of the time students were inattentive, lazy, unpunctual, and bored, with the temptation to do multiple tasks during online learning. Some factors responsible for this inattentiveness were a lack of an interactive teaching approach, a learning environment, and a family burden (Bdair, 2021). Such students lacked the motivation to focus on the lesson, and feeling of isolation with no friends and teachers for interaction when attending online classes at home (Aboagye et al., 2020). The motivation of students is an important factor that has been receiving increasing attention in a recent study in Thailand for successful learning (Laiphrakpam & Aroonsrimorakot, 2021). Therefore, it is essential to have a more interactive and collaborative teaching approach with teachers receiving individual feedback. Teachers should pay attention to monitoring indisciplined students with feedback evaluation, improving the teaching content and the presentation style, and good internet networks to improve the learner's interest in online learning. Support and presence of teachers along with improvement of the quality of teaching materials are factors influencing the success of students gaining knowledge in online classes (Flores et al., 2022;Morris, 2020). In addition to these factors and themes of challenges, respondents provided several suggestions for conducting online classes successfully. These suggestions to overcome the challenges included themes such as evaluation (38.70%), connectivity (27.30%), interactivity (24.10%), content (9.50%), and accessing materials (0.43%). According to participants, teachers should evaluate what has been taught after completing a lesson through a test or homework assignment. Students need to have a stable and fast internet connection to access the internet without interruption for online learning. If the internet is slow, or congested, the sound quality and the video is interrupted, which affects learning. Also, promote online problem-solving applications and group activities among peer students and with teachers for interaction, to motivate students in knowledge acquisition, reduce boredom, and make the lesson more interesting.
Interactions during lessons help in improving peer relationships and encourage the exchange of ideas and thinking processes (Elshami et al., 2022;Moorhouse & Wong, 2022). Further, teachers and learners can do online chat activities to ask and answer questions (Bao, 2020). Unlike the onsite classes, online class settings are replaced by audio and video, which can be interrupted when the internet is slow or if students cannot access the network. In addition, there is a limited and predetermined time for teacher and student interaction, that is when they are logged in to the online class platform only. So, various communication platforms for interaction should be offered to students to promote students' participation and engagement because disconnection with peers in online learning caused them to be isolated learners and limit the opportunity for discussion (Siah et al., 2022). Participants also suggested the structure of course content be brief, concise, easy, up-to-date, applicable in day-to-day life, and not put unnecessary pressure on students. This is because many students struggle to complete the assignment of teachers to pass the course. Many students struggle on their own in online classes as it is quite contrary to onsite education with the presence of a teacher and friends for interaction. The last suggestion was easy to access study material. Videos such as documentaries and recorded audio should be uploaded and provide access to students to save the lesson so that they can watch as many times as they need.

Conclusion
Coronavirus has disrupted every aspect of life including the education system all over the world, including Thailand. To catch up with the curriculum of the academic year, all universities and educational systems switched from onsite to online education mode without much preparation, in terms of training and infrastructure availability. As a result, the study found many challenges which have an impact on the online learning experiences of students in Thailand. Some of the top 10 challenges were a temptation to see other sites, difficulty in understanding the lesson context, poor internet connectivity, difficulty in time management, difficulty in attending online examinations, poor quality of learning experience, low interest/motivation, difficulty in selecting the area at home, difficulty in doing work assignment/task, and distraction at home learning environment. Many students reported factors that caused challenges in online learning. Some of the top factors were distraction due to noise and poor learning environment at home, teacher's incompetency due to technical, poor teaching skills, unstructured content and no follow-up, technological constraint due to the quality of audio/video uploaded, connectivity, technical issue, or data limit. Students also suggested strategies to overcome online learning challenges such as improvement in evaluation, connectivity, interactivity, content and accessing materials. Teachers should evaluate what has been taught after completing a lesson through a test or homework assignment. Students need to have a stable and fast internet connection to access the internet without interruption for online learning. Also, various problem-solving group discussion platforms should be available to encourage students' participation, motivation, engagement, and problem-solving interaction among peer students and with teachers to reduce stress, anxiety, isolation, and boredom and to make the lesson more interesting. As online classes are different from onsite classes, many students struggle on their own at home to complete the workload of the teacher's assignment. So, the course content should be brief, concise, easy, upto-date, and practical and not put unnecessary pressure on students. Students should also be provided easy access to study material, such as audio and videos that can be saved by students for learning as many times as they need. The above analysis shows variation from one student to another in the type of challenges, factors that caused the challenges, and the strategies adopted to overcome those challenges, which can be the effect of personalized, contextualized, and social factors. Lastly, it can be concluded that all these factors and strategies should be considered before implementing online classes successfully. Hence the findings of this study are expected to be beneficial in planning and developing the course content, structure, and infrastructure of online education for effective learning.

Limitation
This study was limited to collecting data on the perception of undergraduate students toward online learning from only two universities in Thailand due to time constraints.